And the results are in

 

23andme Ancestry landing page.

In the hopes of finding some potential connections who only tested at 23andme, I sent off a kit at the beginning of the month. Two weeks later, the results are in and I am looking at comparisons between other tests at Ancestry, MyHeritage and FamilyTreeDNA. 23andme nailed my legacy mtDNA haplogroup, A2d2, while FTDNA's mtFull sequence provides a more refined MitoTree result. For the paternal haplogroup, my Big Y 700 result is definitely more granular than the higher level R-L2.

Before comparing the Ancestry composition results with other tests, it's worth looking at a timeline report from 23andme (below).

23andme. Ancestral timeline.

The report estimates a most recent ancestor from a specific population based on inherited DNA segments. They estimate I had a parent, grandparent or great-grandparent who was 100% English between 1880-1940. Knowing my tree as I do, I know Samuel Oyler was born in Kent, England in 1822. Samuel's son Charles John Oyler (my 2nd-great-grandfather) was half German through my 3rd-great-grandmother Marianna Haiss.

The next interesting entry on the timeline says I had a great-grandparent, 2nd-great-grandparent or 3rd-great-grandparent who was 100% Andalusian, Asturian or Castilian. Here is where some of what I know on my Mexican sides of the tree is useful but incomplete on several of the branches. At the same level, 23andme suggests I also had someone who was 100% Portuguese or Galician, born between 1820 and 1880. I think this was further back, knowing how mixed the people in my tree were about this time.

Between 1760 and 1850, I had most likely a 2nd to 5th-great-grandparent who was Irish. Yes! This would be my 3rd-great-grandmother Bridget, and John O'Brien. 23andme estimates I also had someone at this level who was 100% Scottish. Yes! This was my 5th-great-grandfather John McIntosh. 23andme similarly suggests I had someone at this level who was 100% Austrian or Southern German. Correct, this could come from Marianna Haiss, who was born in Hausen im Killertal in Southern Germany.

Further down in the timeline, there are some fascinating recommendations. 23andme suggests I had a 3rd to 7th-great-grandparent or greater who lived between 1700 and 1820 who was 100% Nigerian. Ancestry's latest origins update from October 2025 estimates this very likely enslaved person was from the Nigerian woodlands, so it's interesting 23andme also shows this trace connection. At this level it also suggests an ancestor who was 100% Southern Mesoamerican (possibly Mayan).

At the lowest level of the timeline, 23andme suggests between 1700-1790, I had an ancestor who was 100% Ashkenazi Jewish, one who was 100% Northern Andean (this is from the Chilean branch of the tree), someone who was 100% French, someone who was 100% Belgian, Rheinlander or Southern Dutch - yes I have this from the du Trieux branch.